Reporting TP for features on side of axial part

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Reporting TP for features on side of axial part

    Hello to everybody.

    Use to run into that issue before, but I would ask you to remind me what I should be aware if I want to report TP for features on the side of axial part.

    For example I want to report TP of holes located on the side of a cylinder (along Z-axis) as deviations of angle and Z.
    As I remember some versions of PC-DMIS did not calculate it right.

    Thank you in advance.

    P.S. TP is a diametrical true position.
    N.

  • #2
    I know of the problem and do not know if it has been fixed. I have the problem on 3.2063 and got into the habit of adjusting my alignment to the z plane for dimensioning TP. That has always been my fix and now, even in V3.7 I still do it. It could be fixed by now for all I know but to be safe I get into the Z plane for TP.

    Craig
    <internet bumper sticker goes here>

    Comment


    • #3
      Craiger, are you talking about when you tp, using Perpindicular to centerline?
      sigpicSummer Time. Gotta Love it!

      Comment


      • #4
        No once upon a time if you TPd in anything but XY it would frog up in some wierd ways. So I just set my alignment for TP dimensions so that I am always doing it in XY. Like I said it may be fixed by now but old habits are hard to break, especially habits to keep PCDMIS from sh1ting on you.
        <internet bumper sticker goes here>

        Comment


        • #5
          Ok, maybe I am missing something here but I normally rotate the Ref Freame about the cylinder axis the basic angle, measure the hole, report the TP, recall the original Ref Frame and the report the angle and Z if needed. Sometimes you have to construct a line through the hole and centerline to get the angle.

          Is that what you said craiger?
          Links to my utilities for PCDMIS

          Comment


          • #6
            I had problems in the past with using the Z axis for TP. X OK, Y OK, PR, and PA ok but as soon as you'd TP in the Z boom, wierd things would happen. It suckd. I am guessing by the puzzled responses this must have been fixed. I guess at this point I'd say that if you TP in the Z axis and wierd things happen it is not fixed, don't blame yourself just align in a manner that you won't have to use Z and drive on. In a nut shell Z axis bad for TP, PCDMIS no like Z for TP. I bet they fixed it but I would never bet too much in Wilcox's favor.

            Craig
            <internet bumper sticker goes here>

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by cmmguy
              Ok, maybe I am missing something here but I normally rotate the Ref Freame about the cylinder axis the basic angle, measure the hole, report the TP, recall the original Ref Frame and the report the angle and Z if needed. Sometimes you have to construct a line through the hole and centerline to get the angle.

              Is that what you said craiger?
              I hate to rotate alignment to the hole. I like to use PR, PA & Z for such features and calculate i, j, k if I do not have a model. And I want to report TP as deviation of Z and PA. But as I remember some versions of PC-DMIS had problem to calculate it right. I am try to find out what versions and the way to work around.
              Thank you.
              N.

              Comment

              Related Topics

              Collapse

              • John Kingston
                TP angle only
                by John Kingston
                I have a part with 5 holes drilled into the circumference of the part. All are in line in Z, but are 10 degrees apart from each other in polar angle....
                08-09-2006, 12:14 PM
              • MIKEY
                TP question
                by MIKEY
                I have a part a square part Dat -A- laying on the surface plate, I am measuring normal to Z+ the part thicknes is 3 inc. I am measuring a cylinder. ...
                10-02-2008, 05:20 PM
              • Paul Sarrach
                TP for GR can be used, if...
                by Paul Sarrach
                You could us TP as for gr if it is TP for only one direction and the gage checks for it. I have a print in front of me that is calling our a TP for...
                03-17-2011, 12:59 PM
              • BANDY
                Revenge of the TP
                by BANDY
                Here as another TP problem. s/b 4x dia .2105 +/-.0015 Tp 0.020 m ABC also tp 0.008 to no datums. When I dimension the holes using Xactmeasure both .020...
                05-12-2008, 05:22 PM
              • PowerJunkie
                Not another TP question!!
                by PowerJunkie
                YES!

                Ok, CMM's don't exist and I need to check the TP to the attached example by means of indicator and v-blocks, that's it. I get a single...
                02-24-2010, 11:38 AM
              Working...
              X