Composite Profile Call-Out to Datum A Twice.

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Composite Profile Call-Out to Datum A Twice.

    I have a part where datum A is a plane, oriented (0, 0, 1). There is a plane below datum A, but also oriented (0, 0, 1).

    The plane below datum A has a composite profile call out as such;

    | .060 | A |
    | .030 | A |

    Isn't this redundant? I am not understanding what this FCF is trying to dimension.

  • #2
    Yes, redundant. I would 'kick it; back to the engineers and ask what hey really want?


    • #3
      Parallelism. The lower tier serves as a refinement of the upper tier. Are you sure that there are no other datums in the upper tier? If not, then you and Brian are correct in that it is redundant. I agree, send it back.


      • #4
        Location and a form refinement ? I don't think its supported by the standard but I'm putting a dollar that's what the engineer is thinking ?


        • brian.freeman
          brian.freeman commented
          Editing a comment
          Then he / she should have just put it as .030 A.

        • Schlag
          Schlag commented
          Editing a comment
          You are loosing available tolerance that way . So why ?

      • #5
        This callout is legit as long as it is composite. The .060 controls orientation AND location. The lower tier controls only controls orientation (parallelism in this case) to .030.


        Related Topics


        • Nguyen
          Profile of plane
          by Nguyen
          I have to measure the profile of 825 nubs with respect to a datum plane. I pick a point on top of each nub then create a best fit plane go through all...
          02-15-2008, 05:12 PM
        • DmisDave
          Questions on creating a Datum?
          by DmisDave
          These pictures are representative of a part I'm checking (not exact). The first pic shows Datum A, a flat plane on the bottom, second pic shows Datum...
          12-10-2012, 10:50 AM
        • akoiro
          FCF issues
          by akoiro
          I am having an odd issue trying to create a profile dimension. I have attached a PDF of a mockup drawing that is the same layout as my part.
          06-29-2020, 12:40 PM
        • Jrcurve
          Profile call of datum A
          by Jrcurve
          Please help me.
          I have a profile call like as ' surface profile 0.02|B|C|' . And the arrow is pointing datum A. What does that mean?. I don't understand...
          11-23-2017, 08:59 PM
        • Liambo734
          Datum Shift
          by Liambo734
          I have measured a profile and reported using XactMeasure. My profile is only constrained to a plane and therefore fixes 3 degrees of freedom in the datum...
          03-18-2015, 06:06 PM